| Ano
| Jogador
|
| 1971 | Willie Mays, San Francisco Giants
|
| 1972
| Brooks Robinson, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1973
| Ao Kaline, Detroit Tigers
|
| 1974
| Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh Pirates
|
| 1975
| Lou Brock, St. Louis Cardinals
|
| 1976
| Pete Rose, Cincinnati Reds
|
| 1977
| Rod Carew, Minnesota Twins
|
| 1978
| Greg Luzinski, Philadelphia Phillies
|
| 1979
| Andre Thornton, Cleveland Indians
|
| 1980
| Phil Niekro, Atlanta Braves
|
| 1981
| Steve Garvey, Los Angeles Dodgers
|
| 1982
| Ken Singleton, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1983
| Cecil Cooper, Milwaukee Brewers
|
| 1984
| Rum Guidry, New York Yankees
|
| 1985
| Dom Baylor, New York Yankees
|
| 1986
| Garry Maddox, Philadelphia Phillies
|
| 1987
| Rick Sutcliffe, Chicago Cubs
|
| 1988
| Dá-lhe Murphy, Atlanta Braves
|
| 1989
| Gary Carter, New York Mets
|
| 1990
| Dave Stewart, Oakland Athletics
|
| 1991
| Harold Reynolds, Seattle Mariners
|
| 1992
| Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1993
| Barry Larkin, Cincinnati Reds
|
| 1994
| Dave Winfield, Minnesota Twins
|
| 1995
| Ozzie Smith, St. Louis Cardinals
|
| 1996
| Kirby Puckett, Minnesota Twins
|
| 1997
| Eric Davis, Baltimore Orioles
|
| 1998
| Sammy Sosa, Chicago Cubs
|
| 1999
| Tony Gwynn, San Diego Pais
|
| 2000
| Ao Leiter, New York Mets
|
| 2001
| Curt Schilling, Arizona Diamondbacks
|
| 2002
| Jim Thome, Cleveland Indians
|
| 2003
| Jamie Moyer, Seattle Mariners
|
| 2004
| Edgar Martinez, Seattle Mariners
|
| 2005
| John Smoltz, Atlanta Braves
|
| 2006
| Carlos Delgado, New York Mets
|
